«

[chainsoar]

<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE(Duss T. @ Mar 13 2007, 11:13 AM) [snapback]283375[/snapback]</div>

Definatley not. And it really bugs me when people try to make a top ten games "ever". There are so many opinions. It is practically impossible for an agreeable to ten. Only ever a partly agreeable. [/b]

I absolutely agree. I couldn't ever whittle it down to ten. All I could say is something like "C&C should be in there somewhere" etc. As for the remark about Doom not defining the fps genre, I agree. I'd say Dark Forces is the one that defined the modern fps.

[BlindMonk]

This isn't just a top ten list. This news story was announced under the guise of a Ten Most Important Games of all times, but really it's the first ten games to be added in this preservation project.

Mr. Lowood’s canon was closely modeled on the work of the National Film Preservation Board, which every year compiles a list of films to be added to the National Film Registry, managed by the Library of Congress since 1989 (a consequence of the National Film Preservation Act, passed in 1988). The first list of films included “Casablanca,” “Citizen Kane,” “The Searchers” and “Nanook of the North.”[/b]

Just as "The Searchers" and "Nanook" are rarely seen at the top of lists (if ever), likewise some of these titles aren't considered the best of their kind or wouldn't factor in too heavily in topping off our usual Top Tens/Hundreds/etc. But this is more about historical weight and what these titles birthed or inspired in the way of modern culture and subsequent game design, art, or gameplay.

[Scatty]

They didn't mention what has defined the RPG scene, though it's actually one of the most important game genres. What a shame. I tend to say it's the Ultima series. These were pretty much defining the gaming scene earlier, already since Ultima 1, many games followed their example. Might be also Rogue.

[nitro]

I think I would have put Dune 2 in the list instead of warcraft, because Dune 2 was the first of the RTS games as we know them now.

[STFM]

Yeah but I think they chose Warcraft because the series as a whole has had a bigger impact on the gaming industry - which is still strange because they specifically chose Mario 3 instead of the original mario...

Where is Pacman? Its synonymous with gaming culture worldwide.

[Lulu_Jane]

I suppose that Pacman is already so ingrained in our cultural minds that it's in danger of being "lost."

[Sathanas]

I'd say some of the games, like Doom, made the FPS genre go sky high. Some others, like Zork, hardly influenced me at all.

[gufu1992]

Your too young... where is C&C and X-com?

[Blood-Pigggy]

C&C was a good game, but Dune 2 did more than C&C: Tiberium Dawn did for the genre (starting it) and X-Com was so unpopular in sales that it could hardly have affected anything.

[gufu1992]

X-com is a legend...